CTE guidelines on publication Ethics

 

Introduction

In its activities, the editorial office of the CTE journal strives to meet the highest standards of publication ethics. The editorial office follows the standards of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) (see: http://publicationethics.org/about).

This policy is an adaptation of COPE recommendations to the specific publication policy of the CTE journal, prepared taking into account the practices of leading international and domestic publishers.

1 Responsibilities of Participants in the Publication Process

The requirements of this policy are mandatory for all participants in the process of publishing a scholarly article in the CTE journal: authors, reviewers, responsible editors, the Editor-in-Chief, members of the editorial board, and the publisher of the journal.

1.1 Responsibilities of Editors

Each editor acknowledges and accepts full responsibility for all published materials.

In their activities, editors are guided by the principles of scholarly integrity, objectivity, impartiality, and editorial independence.

1.2 Responsibilities of Authors

All authors of a manuscript assume full responsibility for its content and for compliance with ethical principles in its creation and publication.

Authors undertake to familiarize themselves with the content of this policy and to follow its requirements, which must be confirmed in writing upon submission of the manuscript;

Authors guarantee that the submitted manuscript:

  • has not been published previously;
  • is not being considered by other journals at the time of submission and will not be submitted to another journal until consideration by the CTE journal is completed;
  • will not infringe the copyright of third parties upon publication;
  • has been approved by all authors;
  • has been approved by the responsible representative of the organization where the research was conducted, if required by its internal regulations.

1.3 Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers undertake to provide substantive, objective, and impartial reviews. Personal criticism of authors is unacceptable.

1.4 Responsibilities of the Publisher

The publisher undertakes not to pressure the journal’s editors to publish materials whose content does not meet the accepted criteria of scholarly value or the journal’s subject area.

2 Transparency of Publishing Processes and Procedures

The editorial office of the CTE journal aims to ensure maximum transparency of publishing processes and procedures, both for participants in the publishing process and for readers.

2.1 Adherence to Accepted Regulations

The editorial office undertakes to follow the procedures described in the following documents:

  • Publication Ethics Policy of the CTE journal;
  • Peer Review Policy of the CTE journal;
  • AI Policy;
  • Procedure for Submission, Review, and Publication of an Article in the CTE Journal.

Departure from these procedures is possible only with justification and subject to timely notification of all interested participants in the editorial process.

2.2 Documentation of the Stages of the Publishing Process

The published text of a scholarly article reflects the dates of the main stages of publication preparation:

  • date of manuscript submission;
  • date of approval of the final version of the manuscript revised in accordance with reviewers’ comments;
  • date of publication of the printed issue containing the text of the article;

3 Conflicts of Interest

3.1 Conflicts of Interest of Authors

Authors undertake to inform the editor of all possible conflicts of interest (financial and non-financial), providing complete and detailed information.

The author must indicate all external sources of funding for the research that resulted in the published article. Information about external sources of research funding must be indicated in the “Funding” section of the article. Funding from organizations indicated in the author’s affiliation is not external and does not require separate indication.

In addition, potential sources of conflicts of interest for each of the authors are:

  • patent rights to a product or technology mentioned in the article;
  • ownership share or employment in a company related to a product or service mentioned in the text of the article.

A connection with a product may be expressed both in the production or distribution of the mentioned product and in that of its direct competitors.

Identified conflicts of interest are declared in the “Conflict of Interest” section of the article if, in the editorial office’s opinion, they may affect the reader’s perception of the article. Upon publication, general information about the existence and nature of the conflict is indicated; details and confidential information are omitted.

The editorial office reserves the right to insist on including certain information in the “Conflicts of Interest” section.

The existence of a conflict of interest must not serve as grounds for excluding a person from the list of authors.

3.2 Conflicts of Interest of Reviewers

If a reviewer has a conflict of interest in connection with the proposed manuscript, they undertake to inform the editor about it before agreeing to review.

If suspicions of a conflict of interest arise during the reviewer’s work with the manuscript, or circumstances are discovered that prevent them from performing the review objectively and impartially, they must inform the editor about this.

In the CTE journal, the following are recognized as a conflict of interest for a reviewer:

  • family or close personal relations with any of the authors;
  • joint publications on the research topic, research projects, or joint grants with any of the authors over the last 3 years;
  • supervisory relations with any of the authors, present or past;
  • employment at the same institution as any of the authors, if this involves direct or indirect subordination (supervisor — subordinate) during the last 3 years;
  • current employment in the same structural unit as one of the authors;
  • financial interests related to the research results (ownership of shares, receipt of funding, fees, or other remuneration from organizations interested in publication of the research);
  • other circumstances that may affect the reviewer’s objectivity (personal interest in the results, competition between the reviewer’s own research and the submitted manuscript, etc.).

The existence of a conflict of interest may serve as grounds for disqualifying a reviewer.

3.3 Conflicts of Interest of Editors

A conflict of interest for an editor is recognized, in particular, as:

  • the existence of joint publications with the authors within 3 years;
  • work in the same research group with the authors currently or within the last 3 years.

If an editor has a conflict of interest in connection with a manuscript submitted for consideration, they must inform the Editor-in-Chief, who makes one of 2 possible decisions:

  • transfer work on the manuscript to another editor;
  • in justified cases (if the conflict of interest can be recognized as insignificant and the editor possesses unique competencies), the editor continues work with the manuscript.

The existence of a conflict of interest on the part of the Editor-in-Chief may serve as grounds for refusing to consider the manuscript.

Regardless of the decision made, all participants in the editorial process are informed about the conflict of interest.

3.4 Conflicts of Interest of the Publisher

The publisher’s commercial interests must not influence the editorial process or the quality of published materials.

Advertising materials are clearly separated from the main content of the journal.

Advertisements must have no connection with the scholarly content of the journal.

3.5 Financial Independence

Publications in the CTE journal are free of charge for authors. No fee is charged for consideration, review, or publication. Sources of research funding do not influence editorial decisions.

4 Authorship

4.1 Authorship Criteria

The manuscript must list all authors who participated in its creation.

Inclusion of a person in the list of authors is determined according to the recommendations of CSE (Council of Science Editors). Each author must simultaneously meet all of the following criteria:

  1. Substantial contribution to the conception and design of the work, or to the collection of data, or to their analysis and interpretation.
  2. Drafting the manuscript or critically revising its content (important intellectual content).
  3. Final approval of the version to be published.
  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work (guaranteeing accuracy and integrity).

Each person included in the list of authors must satisfy all of the listed authorship criteria.

Forms of participation that do not meet authorship criteria:

  • funding of the work;
  • general supervision of the team that conducted the research;
  • performance of work on literary editing, proofreading, or translation of texts.

The CTE journal recognizes the following forms of violation of publication ethics in the area of authorship as unacceptable:

  • “guest authorship,” when persons whose contribution to the work does not meet authorship criteria are included in the list of authors to lend additional authority to the research;
  • “gift authorship,” when persons whose contribution to the work does not meet authorship criteria are included in the list of authors in exchange for a similar service on their part or on a paid basis;
  • “anonymous authorship,” when a person who made a significant contribution to the work on the article is not indicated in the list of authors (for example, writing an article to order on a commercial basis).

4.2 Information About Research Participants

When submitting a manuscript, authors should report the nature of each author’s contribution to the published research and, in particular, to the text of the manuscript. The editorial office reserves the right to additionally request information about each author’s contribution, both from the responsible author and by requesting comments directly from persons of interest to the editorial office.

Persons who participated in the research but whose total contribution does not meet at least one of the criteria specified in clause 4.1 must be indicated in the “Acknowledgements” section with mandatory indication of their contribution.

5 Requirements for Novelty and Scholarly Content of the Publication

5.1 General Requirements

The CTE journal publishes only original, previously unpublished articles that meet the requirements for scholarly novelty, correctness of methods, reliability and validity of data and conclusions, and significance of contribution to the relevant field of knowledge.

Compliance with the listed requirements is confirmed by expert evaluation on the part of editors and reviewers. The journal’s editorial office takes into account adherence to the following rules:

  1. An indication of what exactly constitutes the scholarly novelty must be present in the text of the article and, as far as possible, in the abstract.
  2. The CTE journal prevents the appearance of duplicate publications. If the author already has publications close in content to the submitted one, the article must contain a reference to these publications and specific indications of how the new publication differs from previous ones and why writing it was necessary.

This requirement does not apply to:

  • translations of articles previously published by the authors;
  • articles containing materials previously presented at conferences, including if they were published in collections of materials from the relevant conferences.

An author wishing to publish a translation of their article previously published in another publication must provide the editorial office with written permission from the first publisher, if the original was not published under a license expressly permitting derivative works (for example, Creative Commons BY or BY-SA). The text of the publication must indicate that the material is a translation and provide a full bibliographic reference to the original article.

The CTE journal does not welcome the appearance of redundant publications, which is understood as the practice in which the results of one study are published in small portions in a series of articles in one or different journals.

The CTE journal accepts for publication articles presenting negative research results on the same grounds as all other articles.

5.2 Plagiarism and Copyright

5.2.1 Mandatory Plagiarism Check

All submitted manuscripts undergo a mandatory check using specialized software for detecting borrowed material before being sent for review. Both borrowings from external sources and self-plagiarism (reuse of one’s own previously published texts without proper citation) are subject to checking.

5.2.2 Acceptable Originality Thresholds

Based on the report of the checking system, the editorial office establishes the following guidelines:

For borrowings from third-party sources (excluding self-plagiarism):

  • for original articles: total level of borrowings — no more than 10%, maximum level of borrowings from one source — no more than 3%;
  • for review articles: total level of borrowings — no more than 25%, maximum level of borrowings from one source — no more than 5%.

For self-plagiarism (reuse of one’s own previously published texts):

  • for original articles: total level of self-plagiarism — no more than 15%
  • for review articles: total level of self-plagiarism — no more than 25%

The thresholds for external borrowings and for self-plagiarism are applied independently and are not subtracted from each other. Thus, for an original article, for example, 8% borrowings from external sources and 12% self-plagiarism are acceptable — provided that each of the indicators does not exceed the established threshold. Exceeding at least one of the thresholds is regarded as a violation.

These indicators are approximate and do not serve as the sole criterion for making a decision. Anti-plagiarism systems may record standard terms, generally accepted formulations, and correctly formatted quotations. The decision on whether a violation exists is made on the basis of expert evaluation, and not solely on the basis of a percentage indicator.

5.2.3 Definition of Self-Plagiarism

Self-plagiarism (text recycling) is the reuse by an author of fragments of their own previously published texts without transparent indication of this and without proper citation. At the same time, the new publication must contain a new scholarly result, rather than reproduce previously published data or conclusions.

The editorial office distinguishes:

  • Permissible use of one’s own texts — with mandatory reference to the previous publication, reworking of the material, and the presence of a new result.
  • Impermissible self-plagiarism — copying one’s own texts without reference to the source, presenting previously published material as new, duplicate publications.

The permissible level of self-plagiarism for all types of articles is defined in clause 5.2.2. Exceeding this threshold is regarded as a violation.

5.2.4 Reuse of Graphic Materials

Reuse of figures, graphs, diagrams, photographs, and tables previously published in other publications is permitted only in the following cases:

  • the materials were published under an open license permitting reuse (for example, Creative Commons BY, BY-SA);
  • the author obtained written permission from the rights holder for reuse;
  • at the time of submission of the article, the author / team of authors is the sole rights holder (no exclusive licenses of third parties apply to the materials and there are no other rights holders).

This requirement applies even if the authors of the new article and the authors of the original publication coincide. In all cases of using previously published graphic materials, the author must indicate the source of borrowing (a full bibliographic reference to the original publication) and, if permission exists, attach a copy of it to the manuscript.

Violations regarding the use of graphic materials are classified in accordance with clause 5.2.5 of this Policy depending on the type of material (illustration or data) and the presence of permission and/or reference to the source.

5.2.5 Classification of Violations

Minor plagiarism (including self-plagiarism):

  • verbatim copying of fragments of text amounting to less than 100 words without proper quotation formatting, excluding standard and generally accepted formulations;
  • inaccurate transmission (copying with minor changes) of fragments of text of any length regardless of the presence of a reference to the source, if this does not involve appropriation of data, ideas, or conclusions of another study;
  • use of illustrations (photographs, figures) without indicating the source, but with permission from the rights holder;
  • use of illustrations (photographs, figures) without permission from the rights holder, but with indication of the source;
  • use of images without indicating the source for illustrating the text (photographs, figures) in cases not falling under the signs of significant plagiarism.

Significant plagiarism (including self-plagiarism):

  • verbatim copying of 100 words or more from other sources (including the author’s own works) without proper quotation formatting;
  • resubmission of a publication or its translation under the name of another author, including variants with minor changes;
  • copying data from another study and/or its conclusions without proper reference;
  • use of ideas, hypotheses, or argumentation of other authors without proper attribution;
  • republication of one’s own work or its translation without substantial reworking and without indication of the original (duplicate publication);
  • use of any images (illustrations or data) without permission from the rights holder and without indicating the source;
  • use of images representing research data (graphs, diagrams) without indicating the source regardless of permission from the rights holder.

5.2.6 Actions of the Editorial Office Upon Detection of Plagiarism

If minor plagiarism is detected at the stage of publication preparation, the authors are instructed to make the necessary corrections in the text of the manuscript.

If significant plagiarism is detected:

  • at the stage of publication preparation — the editor has the right to refuse publication of the article at any stage of the publishing process;
  • after publication — the procedure for retraction of the article is initiated.

5.2.7 Author’s Responsibility

Authors are obliged to:

  • upon submission of the article, declare the originality of the submitted manuscript;
  • indicate all sources used in writing the article, including their own previous publications;
  • upon submission of the manuscript, notify the editorial office of any overlapping or previously published materials, and provide copies of such publications;
  • ensure transparency in the use of their own previously published texts by citing and clearly distinguishing new and previously published material.

5.3 Fabrication and Falsification of Data

The editorial office of the CTE journal strives to prevent the publication of articles containing improperly fabricated or falsified data. If, nevertheless, this occurs, the editorial office undertakes to take all actions necessary to eliminate the violations.

Fabrication of data means the invention by the author of research results.

Falsification of data means manipulation of genuine research results in order to create a false impression:

  • editing of images;
  • adding, changing, or deleting elements of a data array.

For the purpose of improving the readability of images, the following manipulations are permitted: adjustment of contrast, brightness, and color balance, provided that they are applied to the entire image and not to its individual parts. If substantive changes were made to the original images, they must be described in the cover letter upon submission of the manuscript to the editorial office.

The editorial office reserves the right to request original data and images from the authors in case of doubts, both during the preparation of the publication and after it.

6 Policy on Peer Review of Manuscripts and Decision-Making on Publication (Ethical Aspects)

This section establishes the ethical principles by which all participants in the review process are guided. The procedural aspects of review (procedure for selecting reviewers, deadlines, requirements for preparing the review, resolution of disputed situations) are regulated in detail by a separate document — the Peer Review Policy of the journal “Computer Tools in Education.”

6.1 Mandatory Nature of Peer Review

All materials containing the results of original scholarly research, review articles, and short communications are subject to peer review. Editorial articles, letters, open reviews, and announcements are not subject to peer review.

6.2 Non-Disclosure of Manuscript Content

Information about the content of the manuscript is not disclosed until its publication. Reviewers are prohibited from discussing or transferring manuscripts to third parties.

6.3 Objectivity and Impartiality

Review must be objective and reasoned. Reviewers are obliged to evaluate the manuscript exclusively on its scholarly content, without regard to the personal qualities of the authors, their nationality, religious beliefs, political views, age, or official status.

Reviewers must not allow statements that are disrespectful toward authors.

6.4 Prevention of Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers are obliged to declare the existence of a conflict of interest before the start of review or immediately upon discovering it in the course of working with the manuscript. The definition of a conflict of interest for reviewers and the procedure for action in such cases are established in this Policy in clause 3.2 and in the Peer Review Policy, clause 1.2.

The editorial office is obliged to take measures to prevent conflicts of interest when selecting reviewers, including for manuscripts whose authors are affiliated with the publishing organization or are members of the editorial board and editorial council.

6.5 Reviewer’s Integrity

A reviewer must:

  • accept a manuscript for review only when confident of their qualifications and ability to complete the work within the established deadline;
  • immediately notify the editorial office of the impossibility of completing the review within the agreed deadline or of insufficient competence to evaluate certain aspects of the manuscript;
  • not transfer the manuscript to third parties for review without the prior consent of the editorial office;
  • inform the editor of any suspicions of violation of publication ethics discovered in the course of review.

The editorial office reserves the right to terminate relations with reviewers who perform their duties in bad faith (delay deadlines, leave meaningless reviews, make disrespectful statements, violate confidentiality).

6.6 Use of Manuscript Materials in One’s Own Research

Use of materials submitted for review, before their publication, in the reviewer’s or editor’s own scholarly work is regarded as a gross violation of publication ethics. An exception is permitted only with the written permission of the authors and only after the editorial office has made a final decision on publication or refusal thereof.

7 Confidentiality

7.1 Confidentiality of the Manuscript

The editor is obliged to maintain the confidentiality of materials provided by the authors.

The editor has no right to report the current status of the manuscript during consideration to anyone other than the authors.

Reviewers have no right to disclose to third parties information about the authors of manuscripts transferred to them for review. Information about the team of authors, their affiliation, and also the very fact that the manuscript was submitted for review to a specific reviewer are confidential. Reviewers are obliged to prevent any situations in which third parties may gain access to the specified information.

7.2 Confidentiality of Reviewers

The editor is obliged to maintain the confidentiality of reviewers. At the same time, a reviewer has the right to disclose their name if they consider it necessary. If a reviewer considers it necessary to exercise their right to disclose their name, they must notify the editor about this in order to avoid possible misunderstandings.

The editorial office is not responsible if the reviewer’s identity is revealed through indirect indications in the text of the letter.

The reviewer’s identity may be disclosed to third parties in the event of reasonable suspicions of ethical violations on their part identified as a result of an investigation, see 9.9.

8 Unfair Editorial Practices

8.1 Regarding Manipulation of Bibliometric Indicators

An editor must not use unfair methods to artificially increase the journal’s bibliometric indicators. In particular, an editor has no right to pressure authors to include in the text of the article references to sources not justified by the scholarly content of the article (for example, references to works published in certain journals, or works by certain authors).

8.2 Regarding Falsification of Review Procedures

The CTE journal does not accept ready-made reviews received from authors. Reviewer candidates proposed by authors undergo a check for conflicts of interest. When appointed, such reviewers declare the absence of a conflict of interest in the same manner as reviewers selected by the editorial office.

9 Description of Procedures

9.1 Procedure for Withdrawal of a Manuscript by Authors

The CTE journal does not charge authors fees for consideration, preparation, and publication of a manuscript; reviewers perform work with the manuscript on a gratuitous basis. Therefore, the right of authors to terminate relations with the editorial office is associated with a number of restrictions.

9.1.1 Withdrawal of a Manuscript Before Its Acceptance for Publication

Before a manuscript is accepted for publication, the responsible author has the right to withdraw the manuscript at any time by sending written notice to the editor. Withdrawal of the manuscript at this stage does not require explanation of the reason.

If the authors intend to withdraw the manuscript, they must notify the editorial office in writing. Submission of the manuscript to another journal before sending such a letter is regarded as a gross violation of publication ethics by the authors.

9.1.2 Withdrawal of a Manuscript Accepted for Publication

Withdrawal of a manuscript accepted for publication is permitted in exceptional cases and only with substantial scholarly or ethical justification, which must be set out in a written statement addressed to the Editor-in-Chief and signed by all authors. Such grounds include the discovery of significant irremediable errors or inaccuracies in data, methodology, analysis, or interpretation of results that cast doubt on the reliability of the entire study.

The withdrawal procedure includes the following stages:

  • submission of a reasoned statement by all co-authors with attached supporting materials;
  • consideration of the statement at a meeting of the editorial board with the involvement of independent experts (if necessary);
  • issuance by the Editor-in-Chief of a decision to remove the manuscript from publication or to refuse withdrawal with public argumentation.

If the Editor-in-Chief recognizes the reason given by the authors as insufficiently valid, but the authors insist on withdrawal contrary to the editorial office’s decision, such a manuscript is removed from publication at the authors’ request. At the same time, the editorial office reserves the right in the future to reject new submissions from these authors without consideration for a period determined by the editorial board.

9.2 Procedure for Rejection of a Manuscript by the Editorial Office

All decisions to reject a manuscript at any stage are made by the Editor-in-Chief on the basis of reasoned recommendations of the editor and reviewers. Authors are notified of the decision made with mandatory indication of the specific reasons for rejection.

9.2.1 Rejection of a Manuscript at the Stage of Initial Expert Review

At the stage of initial consideration, a manuscript is subject to rejection without being sent for review in cases where its content does not correspond to the scholarly profile of the journal, its formatting does not meet established requirements, the level of the presented results does not possess sufficient scholarly novelty, or clear signs of violation of academic ethics are identified, including borrowings without proper citation.

9.2.2 Rejection on Organizational and Ethical Grounds

The editorial office reserves the right to reject a manuscript if, with respect to the research topic, there is no possibility of involving qualified reviewers, and also in the event of identifying an irremediable conflict of interest on the part of the editor or members of the editorial board that prevents objective consideration.

9.2.3 Rejection of a Manuscript Based on Review Results

Based on the results of review, a manuscript is rejected upon receipt of negative conclusions from reviewers, and also in the event that the authors were unable to convincingly refute substantial comments or present persuasive counter-arguments. Grounds for rejection also include the impossibility of eliminating the identified deficiencies without radical reworking of the work.

9.2.4 Rejection in Connection with Violation of Deadlines and Procedure for Revision

In the event of systematic delay by authors in making revisions without valid reasons, and also if it is impossible to revise the manuscript to the required level after the next stage of substantial revision, the editorial office has the right to reject the manuscript without further review.

9.2.5 Procedure for Rejection of a Manuscript Accepted for Publication

The editorial office reserves the right to reject a previously accepted manuscript before its placement in an issue if, after acceptance of the material, circumstances are identified that cast doubt on the integrity of the authors or the reliability of the work. Such grounds include:

  • discovery of irremediable errors affecting the conclusions;
  • confirmation of parallel submission to another journal;
  • identification of plagiarism or improper borrowings not noticed earlier;
  • receipt of new data on fabrication or falsification of empirical materials;
  • undisclosed conflict of interest significantly affecting interpretation of the results;
  • refusal by the authors to make mandatory corrections recognized by the editorial office as necessary, when the argumentation presented by the authors is unconvincing.

A manuscript may also be rejected if the authors, by their actions or inaction, impede the normal publication process.

The rejection procedure is initiated by the editor or the Editor-in-Chief, after which the Editor-in-Chief appoints an additional check, including with the involvement of external experts and, if necessary, with the involvement of the authors. Based on the results of consideration, the Editor-in-Chief issues a reasoned written decision, which is communicated to the authors.

Authors may file an appeal against the editorial office’s decision in accordance with clause 9.10.

9.3 Procedure for Making Proofreading Corrections to the Manuscript

During the preparation of a manuscript, there is usually a need to make changes to the text of the manuscript received by the editorial office.

Proposals for making changes may come from:

  • the technical staff of the editorial office — regarding bringing the manuscript into compliance with the formatting standards adopted in the journal;
  • the editor — regarding compliance with the requirements of this policy in terms of disclosing information about conflicts of interest, funding sources, eliminating citation violations, etc.;
  • reviewers — regarding the scholarly content of the article (which does not exclude, if necessary, indications of ethical violations);
  • the proofreader — regarding elimination of language and technical errors without changing the author’s meaning and factual content.

All correspondence regarding the changes being made is conducted by the editor with the authorized author. If necessary, other authors may participate in the correspondence.

If the editorial office considers the proposed argumentation unconvincing, but the authors continue to insist on their position, this may serve as grounds for rejecting the manuscript (see clause 9.2.5 of this policy).

Mandatory corrections, refusal of which may entail rejection of the manuscript, include, in particular: disclosure of conflicts of interest, indication of funding sources, elimination of improper borrowings, correction of factual errors in data or conclusions, bringing the manuscript into compliance with the formatting requirements established by the journal.

In the absence of a response from the authors regarding mandatory corrections after three notifications with an interval of at least 3 working days, the editorial office sends the authors a final notification with a list of specific mandatory corrections, indication of violated requirements, and a deadline for response of at least 10 working days. If the authors do not respond within the specified period, the editorial office has the right to reject the manuscript in accordance with clause 9.2.5 of this policy or to suspend preparation of the publication until a response from the authors is received.

9.4 Procedure for Making Changes to the List of Authors

9.4.1 Procedure for Making Changes to the List of Authors Before Publication

A request to change the list of authors on the part of the responsible author (or another person) must be accompanied by a reasoned statement of the reasons for such a decision.

The editorial office requests the consent of all authors, including those added to and removed from the list.

If consent is not obtained, the process of preparing the publication is suspended until the dispute between the authors is resolved.

If all authors have confirmed their consent, after fulfilling the requirements, the corresponding changes are made to the manuscript.

In the case of adding an author, information about their contribution to the work must be provided, their familiarity with and obligation to follow the requirements of this policy must be confirmed, and an agreement on transfer of rights to the work must be signed.

9.4.2 Procedure for Making Changes to the List of Authors After Publication

When adding a new author, in addition to justifying the necessity of these actions, an explanation must be provided as to why this was not done upon submission of the manuscript.

If the explanation indicates a violation of publication ethics, the procedure for investigating violations under 9.9 is initiated.

If the explanation is recognized as satisfactory, the editorial office requests the consent of all authors, including those added to and removed from the list.

If consent is not obtained, the editorial office will use all available means to resolve the conflict as quickly as possible in one way or another.

If consent is obtained, the procedure for correcting the article under 9.6 is initiated.

A special case is a request to make a change to the list of authors in the event that one of the authors disagrees with the interpretation of the research data: such an author, as well as their opponents among the other authors of the article, must be given the right to publish a letter setting out their position. The editorial office reserves the right to refuse publication of letters if they are meaningless or contain libel, personal attacks, and similar violations.

9.4.3 Resolution of Authorship Disputes

The editorial office does not participate in resolving authorship disputes and does not act as an arbitrator in them. At the same time, given the editorial office’s responsibility for the reliability of published materials, in the event of a protracted conflict, the editorial office may contact the organizations at the authors’ places of work with a request to conduct an investigation. If this also does not lead to a result, the editorial office reserves the right to publish a notice of expression of concern (section 9.7).

9.5 Approval of the Layout and Publication

The decision on publication is made by the editor on the basis of the scholarly value of the manuscript and the reviewers’ reports. When making the decision, the editor is guided exclusively by the scholarly content of the work, without regard to the personal characteristics of the authors. The final layout of the article is subject to approval by the responsible author. Publication is permitted only after approval of the layout.

In the absence of a response from the author regarding the layout after three notifications with an interval of 3 working days, the editorial office has the right to consider the layout approved. In this case, only technical and language corrections that do not change its meaning are made to the text. All co-authors are sent notification of the article’s release with indication of a deadline for objections — 5 working days. In the absence of objections within the specified period, the article is considered approved by all authors.

If the author refuses to approve the layout or demands changes that contradict the journal’s requirements or distort the scholarly content of the work, this is regarded as refusal to approve. In such a case, the editorial office acts in accordance with the procedure provided for in clause 9.3 of this Policy.

9.6 Making Changes to the Text of an Article After Its Publication

Making changes to the text of an article after its publication is permitted only in exceptional cases in the presence of substantial grounds: discovery of significant factual errors, misprints, or inaccuracies in data, formulas, or references, technical errors of the editorial office in layout, as well as clarifications that increase the transparency of the research but do not change the main conclusions. Stylistic corrections, improvement of formulations, and updating of references (except critically important cases) are not grounds for making changes.

9.6.1 Making Changes at the Initiative of the Authors

Authors who discover the need for changes send a written statement addressed to the Editor-in-Chief with a description of the changes, justification of their necessity, and confirmation of the consent of all co-authors. The Editor-in-Chief considers the statement and makes a decision to grant it or to refuse it with reasons. In the event of refusal, the authors have the right to file an appeal in accordance with the procedure provided for in section 9.10 of this Policy.

9.6.2 Making Changes at the Initiative of the Editorial Office

The editorial office has the right to initiate changes upon discovery of technical errors made during preparation of the publication, and also in the event of identifying, in the course of an investigation (clause 9.9), violations requiring correction of individual elements of the article but not entailing full retraction. The editorial office notifies the responsible author of the planned changes with justification of the reasons and provides a period of at least 10 working days for submission of objections. In the absence of objections, the changes are made unilaterally. In the presence of disagreements, the final decision is made by the Editor-in-Chief.

9.6.3 Formalization of Changes

All changes are formalized by publishing the corrected text of the article on the journal’s website while preserving the original publication date and a separate correction notice, which contains a full bibliographic reference to the original article, the date of correction, a description of the changes made, the basis (at the initiative of the authors or the editorial office), and the surname of the Editor-in-Chief who approved the changes. The notice is placed on the website and attached to the electronic version of the article. Changes are not made in the print version. If necessary, the notice is published in one of the subsequent issues.

9.7 Formalization of a Notice of Expression of Concern

When deciding to publish a notice of expression of concern, the editorial office places it on the journal’s website and, if necessary, in the nearest print issue. The notice contains:

  • a full bibliographic reference to the article in respect of which concern is expressed;
  • the date of publication of the notice;
  • a description of the grounds for expressing concern with indication of the nature of the unresolved issues;
  • information about the initiator (authors, editorial office, third parties);
  • signature of the Editor-in-Chief.

On the electronic version of the article on the journal’s website, a note “EXPRESSION OF CONCERN” is placed with attachment of the text of the notice. The text of the article remains accessible, but the reader is informed of the existence of reasonable doubts about the reliability of the work.

9.8 Procedure for Retraction of a Published Article

Retraction of a published article is an extreme measure applied in cases where the reliability or integrity of the work is called into question so seriously that correction is insufficient to eliminate the violations.

9.8.1 Grounds for Retraction

Retraction is carried out on the following grounds:

  • gross violations of publication ethics — significant plagiarism (including self-plagiarism), fabrication or falsification of data, duplicate publications, improper borrowing of ideas or results of other researchers;
  • irremediable errors — discovery of critical errors in methodology, calculations, interpretation of data, or conclusions that cannot be corrected by correction and that cast doubt on the reliability of the entire study;
  • copyright infringement — publication without the consent of all authors, use of third-party materials without permission, violation of the rights of rights holders;
  • undisclosed conflict of interest — if a conflict of interest significantly affecting interpretation of the results was not declared upon submission of the manuscript and its disclosure after publication changes the perception of the work;
  • court decision or requirement of an authorized body — a court decision that has entered into force or an order of a regulatory body obliging retraction of the publication.

9.8.2 Initiation of the Retraction Procedure

Retraction may be initiated by:

  • the authors (all co-authors or responsible authors with the consent of the others);
  • the journal’s editorial office (based on the results of its own check or investigation provided for in section 9.9);
  • third parties (readers, reviewers, representatives of the scholarly community) in the presence of reasonable evidence of violations.

An application or communication regarding the need for retraction is submitted to the Editor-in-Chief in written form with attached supporting materials.

9.8.3 Consideration Procedure

The retraction procedure includes the following stages:

  1. Preliminary check — the Editor-in-Chief appoints an editor or member of the editorial board to conduct an initial check of the validity of the application. Deadline — no more than 14 working days.
  2. Investigation — if the validity of the application is confirmed, a full investigation is initiated in accordance with the procedure provided for in section 9.9 of this Policy. Independent experts who have no conflict of interest with the authors may be involved in the investigation.
  3. Notification of authors — the authors are notified of the start of the investigation and are given the opportunity to present their explanations and counter-arguments within a period of at least 14 working days.

Decision-making — based on the results of the investigation, the Editor-in-Chief issues a reasoned decision on retraction or refusal thereof. The decision is drawn up in writing and communicated to the authors and the applicant.

9.8.4 Formalization of Retraction

When deciding on retraction, the editorial office publishes a retraction notice on the journal’s website and in the nearest print issue. The retraction notice contains:

  • a full bibliographic reference to the retracted article;
  • the date of retraction;
  • the grounds for retraction with indication of the nature of the violations;
  • information about the initiator of the retraction (authors, editorial office, third parties);
  • signature of the Editor-in-Chief.

On the electronic version of the article on the journal’s website, a note “RETRACTED” is placed with attachment of the retraction notice.

The text of the article is preserved in the journal’s archive but is marked as retracted so as not to mislead readers.

9.8.5 Actions in Case of Refusal of Retraction

If, based on the results of the investigation, a decision is made to refuse retraction, the editorial office:

  • sends the authors and the applicant a reasoned written decision;
  • if necessary, may publish a notice of expression of concern in cases where violations have not been proven but reasonable doubts remain about the reliability of the work (regulated by section 9.7 of this Policy).

9.8.6 Interaction with Organizations

In cases where the grounds for retraction are related to violations affecting the interests of the organization where the research was conducted (fabrication, falsification, plagiarism), the editorial office notifies the relevant organization and, if necessary, provides the investigation materials for conducting an internal inquiry (clause 9.9).

9.9 Procedure for Investigating Cases of Unethical Behavior of Participants in the Publishing Process

9.9.1 Initiation of the Investigation

The main task of the editorial office when suspicions of dishonest actions arise is to ensure the quality of published materials. The investigation is conducted in order to establish the compliance of the manuscript or already published article with the norms of publication ethics and to determine the necessary editorial actions.

The investigation is initiated by the Editor-in-Chief on the basis of:

  • a written application from authors, reviewers, members of the editorial board, or third parties;
  • the results of a check of the manuscript or published article conducted by the editorial office;
  • the Editor-in-Chief’s own initiative upon identifying signs of a violation.

An application or communication about a violation is submitted to the Editor-in-Chief in written form with attached supporting materials (if any). Information about a violation may be brought to the attention of the editorial office by any interested person. Anonymous applications are accepted for consideration only in cases where they contain sufficient factual grounds for verification.

The Editor-in-Chief has the right to reject an application without conducting an investigation if it does not contain specific facts or is clearly unfounded. The applicant is notified of the refusal in writing with indication of the reasons.

9.9.2 Scope and Results of the Investigation

The policy applies both to violations identified in the process of preparing a publication (from the moment of receipt of the manuscript) and after publication. In the first case, the result of the investigation is a decision to refuse publication or to continue work on the manuscript. In the second case, it is a decision on the need to retract the article.

Determination of the degree of guilt and application of punitive measures in relation to specific persons falls within the competence of the organizations with which the authors are affiliated.

9.9.3 Principles of the Investigation

In conducting the investigation, the editorial office is guided by impartiality, confidentiality in relation to the suspected persons, mandatory recording of all correspondence (including evidence, complaints, and unsubstantiated allegations), conduct of the investigation within reasonable timeframes, and also by the striving to establish the truth and openness to discussion for all parties to the proceedings.

9.10 Procedure for Filing an Appeal Against a Decision of the Editorial Office

The editorial office accepts appeals only in cases where the manuscript was accepted for consideration and sent for review.

Appeals against the following actions of the editor are accepted for consideration:

  • unjustified refusal of publication (provided that at least one of the reviewers recommended the manuscript for publication);
  • incorrect selection of reviewers;
  • a requirement to make changes to the text of the article that are unacceptable from the authors’ point of view.